Second Ferment: Key Lime Pie, Milk kefir yogurt, Recipe (Raw)

Milk kefir yogurt that taste like your favorite southern pie.

This is a thick, creamy, tangy, sweet kefir yogurt.

Buy kombucha, milk kefir & water Kefir

What you need:

  • 2 quart jars with lids (or half gallon jar)
  • Fresh key lime juice or bottled (1/2 cup)
  • Key Lime zest (1 tsp)
  • Optional: Thinly sliced key lime (1)
  • Finished kefired milk (2 cups)
  • Finished kefired cheese (3 cups)
  • 1/2 cup kefired heavy whipping cream
  • Real vanilla extract (1 tsp)
  • Optional: Pomona’s Pectin (1 tbsp)
  • Organic sugar (1 tbsp) (optional or you might just use less).

Extra info:

Key Limes: Best to use fresh key limes & juice but if you can not get them bottled juice is fine & using lime zest or no zest & adding the slices is optional.

Finished Kefir milk: Go to my blog post here to learn how to make milk kefir.

Finished Kefir cheese: Learn how to make milk kefir cheese here.

Kefir heavy whipping cream: Just simply use your grains to kefir some heavy whipping cream, if you are worried about adding your grains to heavy whipping cream simply just add the whipping cream un-kefired.

Pomona’s Pectin: This is optional but can help thicken the yogurt.

Key lime pie milk kefir yogurt

Organic sugar: Depending on your own taste you might want to add a little sugar or no sugar.


  1. add your milk kefir, cheese, whipping cream, vanilla & key lime juice to blender (Or Ninja etc).
  2. Blend.
  3. Scrape sides.
  4. add key lime zest, Pectin, sugar to blender.
  5. Blend
  6. Scrape sides.
  7. Divide into quart jars.
  8. add some thin sliced key lime to each jar,
  9. Stir
  10. Screw lids on.
  11. Sit on counter 1 hour to several hours depending on temps.
  12. Do not allow to separate (if it does you can mix it with a spoon, but it might get really tart if it separates).
  13. Sit in fridge until chilled.
  14. Enjoy
  15. Serving idea, eat with graham crackers.

Buy on Amazon:

Key Lime Pie Milk kefir yogurt

This slideshow requires JavaScript.

Affiliate & Referral links:  I do when I can have links that are affiliate or referral links, not all links on my blog, pages & posts are affiliate or referral links. (More info here)

I will  share links to buy products on  Amazon  anytime I can, I thank you for your support.


Follow me:  Facebook  –  Pinterest  –  Google+  –  Instagram  (Raising6kids) –   Twitter  @NaturalCheree

Click here to learn where buy some of my favorite products  such as coconut oil, colloidal silver & more.

All    information contained in the pages of Natural & Frugal: Raising 6 kids blog – NFR6K Blog, blog posts, site, Facebook page, Twitter, Pinterest or elsewhere are for information & research only.

Natural & Frugal: Raising 6 kids  &  NFR6K Reviews

To contact me to review your product go here.

More products I love by Tropical Traditions:    Gold Label Virgin Coconut oil  –  Green label Virgin coconut oil  –  Palm Oil  –  Palm shortening  –  Extra Virgin Olive oil  –  Black Cumin Seed oil  –  Organic Sesame oil  –  Coconut water Vinegar  –  Organic Apple cider vinegar  –  Balsamic vinegar  –  Pink Himalayan salt  –  Organic spices  –  Organic Whole Unbleached Sugar  –  Grass-Fed butter  & more.

If you order by clicking on any of my links & order from Tropical Traditions & have never ordered from them in the past, you might receive a free book on Virgin Coconut Oil, & I will receive a discount coupon for referring you”

back nfr6k


I only recommend products or services I use personally and believe will be good for my readers. Thank you for reading my blog & supporting me on the journey to share #NFR6K Cheree

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s